By Dr Daniel Johnson2024-05-08T11:09:00
Lord Williams of Oystermouth says many of the hymns sung at weddings and funerals, including ‘All things bright and beautiful’, are comparable to “baby food”. But hymn scholar Dr Daniel Johnson says churches should be sharing the treasures of the hymn tradition with as much joy as possible
A debate over the place of hymns in our society was sparked last week when Lord Lisvane wrote the following letter to The Times, “We are fortunate in this country to have such a splendid repertoire of hymns…Why, then, do we have to suffer All Things Bright and Beautiful? It is chosen by about half the participants in the weddings I play for (though I am often successful in helping them to choose something better)…I find the saccharine doggerel, combined with the jingly tune (not that easy for congregations to sing, actually), deeply depressing — especially when there are so many wonderful alternatives.”
In a subsequent Times news story The former Archbishop of Canterbury, Rowan Williams, now Lord Williams of Oystermouth, agreed there are many “great classics” and lamented how these had “fallen out of common memory”.
Register FREE or SIGN IN HERE if you are a subscriber, a registered user, or if you already have a login for another Premier website
It only takes a minute to sign up for a free account and unlock these benefits:
Want more? Subscribe today and get UNLIMITED ACCESS!
Get more free content register today or sign in now
2024-10-29T11:59:00Z By Peter Lynas
Why has the Archbishop of Canterbury changed his mind on gay sex? Peter Lynas believes it’s because the Archbishop has adopted a view of morality which is based more on personal preference than objective standards
2024-10-29T10:25:00Z By Tony Wilson
Should our prayers be set, or spontaneous? Tony Wilson suggests that liturgy should be used as a springboard for our own personal prayers. He explains why
2024-10-28T12:50:00Z By Ashleigh Hull
When Ashleigh Hull was a teenager, biblical teaching on marriage and sexuality seemed far from good to her. Here’s how she changed her mind
2024-10-29T10:11:00Z By George Pitcher
The Met’s decision to release more information on Chris Kaba’s “character”, presents us with some worrying ethical issues, says George Pitcher
2024-10-25T14:03:00Z By James Mildred
Parliament could be weeks away from voting to legalise assisted suicide. But it’s not a done deal. There are good reasons to think it could be defeated, and there’s still time for you to act, says James Mildred
2024-10-25T11:15:00Z By Guy Hewitt
The Church of England’s director of racial justice Guy Hewitt says he’s wrestling with “a growing pessimism” when it comes to combatting racism. But this Black History Month, he’s choosing to look to Jesus, and the ultimate hope that is found in him
Site powered by Webvision Cloud