A female Jesus? Christians are right to be offended
By 
Kate Orson2025-03-04T14:14:00
Grammy award-winning British actor, Cynthia Erivo, will become the first woman to play Jesus in a major production of Jesus Christ Superstar. Kate Orson says the decision is blasphemous, but Christians should take care in expressing themselves
See here for an alternative perspective on this story
Actress and singer Cynthia Erivo has been cast in the role of Jesus in the Hollywood Superbowl production of the musical Jesus Christ Superstar which will be performed in Los Angeles this summer.
Many Christians have already taken to social media to express dismay at the casting, considering it blasphemy, and I agree with them.
Jesus Christ Superstar has been controversial since its debut in 1971. Christians have long objected to the musical’s portrayal of Jesus as an imperfect human rather than the perfect son of God. There is also an implied romance between Jesus and Mary Magdalene, and Judas is depicted sympathetically. Billy Graham once described it as “bordering on blasphemy and sacrilege”.
The musical was never purported to be a faithful rendering of the Gospel story, so we perhaps shouldn’t expect it to be. However, casting a woman in the role of Jesus is a step too far, and I can’t help thinking it’s a deliberate act to mock God.
Christians are right to be upset about this. In previous decades there would be a certain reverence and respect for…
Related articles
-
OpinionMeryl Streep as Aslan doesn’t have to be an attack on Christianity
News that a female actor will be voicing Aslan in Greta Gerwig’s upcoming adaptation of The Magician’s Nephew has led some Christians to accuse the director of blasphemy. But Christians need not view this decision as an attack on our faith, says Tabbi Kibugi
-
OpinionU2 at 50: How Bono's band became icons of rock by singing about God
On Saturday, 25th September 1976, four teenagers decided to get together to make music. Fifty years of faith-fuelled songs later, Steve Stockman charts the spiritual journey of Saint Bono and his band
-
ReviewsIf Oasis don’t look back in anger, neither should we
The new documentary about rock and roll’s warring brothers is not a tour movie, but a moving tale of reconciliation, says Martin Saunders - with a surprising cameo from their local priest. If Noel and Liam can forgive, there’s hope for us all
More from Opinion
-
OpinionShould Christians be stockpiling for a national emergency?
With warnings of war, cyberattacks and climate disruption, preparing for disaster no longer seems the preserve of conspiracy theorists. As the UK government urges households to keep a few days’ supply of non-perishable food as part of its new ‘Prepare’ campaign, Rev Jules Middleton considers what the Bible says about preparedness, fear and loving our neighbours
-
OpinionMost UK evangelicals hold unbiblical views on sin and salvation
61% of UK evangelicals believe most people are good by nature, according to a new survey. Dr Samuel Tunnicliffe warns that such beliefs risk emptying the gospel of its true power
-
OpinionShould Christians still be on X?
X is home to trolls, deepfakes and outrage. There might be good reasons to leave. But Lois Mclatchie Miller warns that if Christians abandon every flawed public forum, our light will never be able to shine in the darkness
- Issues
- Topics A-Z
- Writers A-Z
- © 2026 Premier Christianity
Site powered by Webvision Cloud