Explained: Why did this Christian baker refuse to make a gender transition cake?
By 
Heather Tomlinson2024-10-15T08:53:00
The US-based baker Jack Phillips has been heavily criticised for refusing to make cakes which promote LGBT messages. After a lengthy legal battle, the Colorado Supreme Court has thrown the case out. Heather Tomlinson reports
Why are ‘gay’ cakes in the news again?
Masterpiece Cakeshop owner Jack Phillips has been in a long legal battle with transgender lawyer Autumn Scardina, who had asked Phillips’ small family business to bake a cake to celebrate gender transition in 2017, but been refused. Now, the Colorado Supreme Court has decided it doesn’t have jurisdiction to make this decision and so dismissed the case.
What actually happened?
According to court documents…
Related articles
-
OpinionThe first conviction for silent prayer in British history should terrify us all
The conviction of Adam Smith-Connor for silent prayer inside an abortion clinic “buffer zone” marks an era-defining moment. The law needs clarifying urgently, says Lois McLatchie-Millar, before the UK’s human right’s record becomes an international laughing stock
-
OpinionLetting children identify as animals is wrong
Some Scottish schools are officially recognising species dysphoria and allowing students to identify as ‘furries’. Lizzie Harewood, CEO of the Association of Christian Teachers, says a compassionate ‘no’ to this contested ideology is the right response
-
OpinionRT Kendall: I’m pleading with Donald Trump – do not make God your enemy
Donald Trump says he wants to go to heaven. But RT Kendall warns that the President’s refusal to forgive his enemies puts him at odds with Jesus – and urges him to repent before it’s too late
More from News Analysis
-
News AnalysisThree years on from the 7 October attacks, neither Israelis nor Palestinians are safer
Three years ago, Gavin Drake warned that Hamas’s 7 October attack would bring a brutal Israeli response and catastrophe for Gaza. As he revisits what he got right and what he didn’t foresee, he points to the evidence that neither Israeli security nor Palestinian freedom will be won through the destruction of the other
-
News AnalysisThe Green Party is ‘anti-Zionist’. But what is Zionism and how should Christians view the term?
The Green Party has adopted a definition that builds exclusion and domination into Zionism’s very meaning. But Zionism encompasses a far wider and more diverse tradition, explains Gavin Drake
-
News AnalysisMacklemore was dropped from Ed Sheeran’s tour for saying ‘Free Palestine’. What does it really mean?
Macklemore has been dropped from Ed Sheeran’s US tour following his “Free Palestine” comments. But what does the phrase mean and is it inherently antisemitic? Gavin Drake takes a look at the various ways those two contentious words are understood
- Issues
- Topics A-Z
- Writers A-Z
- © 2026 Premier Christianity
Site powered by Webvision Cloud