In defence of ‘childless cat ladies’
By 
Chine McDonald2024-08-01T08:26:00
JD Vance is wrong to pick on childless women, says Chine McDonald. Without their commitment and service, the Church would not exist
Some of my best friends are ‘cat ladies’ – the offensive slur describing childless women used by JD Vance, the US Republican vice-presidential nominee – that sparked global outrage last month when an old interview of him resurfaced.
Criticising the current vice-president Kamala Harris, Vance said: “We’re effectively run in this country… by a bunch of childless cat ladies who are miserable at their own lives and the choices that they’ve made”. Vance also argued that not having children meant you had no ‘direct stake’ in the future.
This argument that being childless – whether by choice or being single not by choice or because of fertility challenges, or baby loss – is not just confined to fiery US elections. In the 2016 Conservative leadership race, Andrea Leadsom apologised after appearing to suggest she’d make a better prime minister because she was a mother, and her opponent, Theresa May was not. Leadsom had said that her motherhood meant she “had a very real stake in the future”, implying that those who were not mothers did not.
Related articles
-
Opinion4 things women want from church
It might be controversial, but as she enters the second half of life, Deborah Sloan is finally raising her head above the parapet. Here’s four things women want – and need – to find refreshment, renewal and restoration in their faith
-
OpinionThe public are clear about their position on abortion up to birth. The Church should be too
Parliament has once again pushed the boundaries of abortion law, but the public remain unconvinced — with just 1 per cent of women supporting abortion up to birth, notes Lois McLatchie-Miller. As the law moves further than most are comfortable with, the Church must speak clearly and courageously for both mother and child, she argues
-
OpinionPeople come to church for all sorts of reasons. We must give them the reason to stay: Christ
Esther Walker’s account of attending church as a newcomer in The Times is no typical revival story. Drawn in by her son’s cricket superstitions and kept by an amusing vicar, Rev Peter Crumpler says her honest reflections offer vital lessons for how the Church reaches those outside its walls
More from Columnists
-
OpinionWe don’t need hypermasculine world leaders. We need ones who lead like Jesus
Global politics is dominated by displays of strength, aggression and ‘tough’ masculinity, says Chine McDonald. The life of Christ offers a radically different vision of both manhood and servant leadership
-
Regular ColumnistsMy daughter plays the ‘yellow car’ game. Here’s what it taught me about faith
Gemma Hunt explains how a lighthearted game got her thinking about bringing faith into everyday life
-
Regular ColumnistsWilling to die? Why Christians need to recover their moral courage
Western Christians may never face execution for their faith, but we are still called to costly obedience. Chine McDonald considers what moral courage looks like today
- Issues
- Topics A-Z
- Writers A-Z
- © 2026 Premier Christianity
Site powered by Webvision Cloud